Smartphones are more than communication tools. They’re companions for work, entertainment, and staying connected with the world. December 2024 has brought some exceptional flagship devices from Apple, Samsung, and Google, each vying for the title of the best smartphone of the year.
This in-depth guide will pit the iPhone 16 Pro Max, Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, and Google Pixel 9 Pro against each other. From their designs to performance, cameras to battery life, we’ll explore everything, helping you choose the right phone for your priorities.
1. Design & Build Quality
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
Apple once again proves its mastery of design. The iPhone 16 Pro Max features a 6.9-inch Super Retina XDR OLED display, framed by elegant FrostEdge Glass. Its slim bezels make the screen feel edge-to-edge without increasing the phone’s overall size, making it compact for its display dimensions.
Key Design Features:
- Material: Grade 5 titanium frame for robustness without adding weight.
- Colors: Stunning finishes such as Arctic Blue, Charcoal Black, and Sunset Gold.
- Durability: IP68 water and dust resistance, alongside an advanced scratch-resistant coating.
User Experience:
- Many find the matte-textured back great for fingerprint resistance.
- Comfortable grip, but its large size may feel bulky for users accustomed to smaller devices.
Verdict: Minimalistic yet premium, the iPhone 16 Pro Max blends practicality with elegance.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Samsung continues to push boundaries with its futuristic AeroMetal Frame, making the Galaxy S24 Ultra lightweight but highly durable. Its 6.8-inch Quad HD+ AMOLED display is built for visuals with vivid colors and sharpness.
Key Design Features:
- Display: A stunning 3120 x 1440 resolution offers cinematic viewing quality.
- Colors: Eye-catching hues like Nebula Silver, Cosmic Green, and Midnight Blue.
- Build Quality: Reinforced Gorilla Glass Victus 3 protects against drops and scratches.
User Experience:
- Slim profile despite the massive display.
- Ergonomically curved edges make it easier to hold.
Verdict: A sleek, futuristic design that screams luxury, perfect for users who love large, visually stunning screens.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Google’s sleek compact design ethos is embodied in the Pixel 9 Pro. It boasts a 6.3-inch OLED display, smaller yet vibrant enough for any application. Its aluminum build gives it a polished yet sturdy feel in your hands.
Key Design Features:
- Compact Form: A smaller screen that’s ideal for one-hand usage.
- Vibrancy: Deep blacks and punchy colors with HDR10+ support.
- Build Quality: Slim but sturdy with IP68 durability testing approval.
User Experience:
- Lightweight and design-focused.
- Perfect for users who value portability over larger screen sizes.
Overall Winner: iPhone 16 Pro Max masters elegance and durability, while the Galaxy S24 Ultra impresses with its bold display. For compact lovers, Pixel 9 Pro wins the game.
2. Performance & Software
Performance determines how a smartphone handles demanding apps, multitasking, and gaming. Each competitor stands out—Apple leads in speed, Samsung excels at customizability, and Google focuses on AI excellence.
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
The latest A18 Pro chipset inside the iPhone 16 Pro Max takes speed and efficiency to the next level. Built on a 3-nanometer process, it’s not only faster but also power-efficient. Coupled with iOS 18, this phone delivers seamless performance.
Top Technical Specs:
- Chipset: A18 Pro with 6-core CPU and 16-core Neural Engine.
- Storage and RAM: Options range from 256GB to 1TB, supported by 8GB RAM.
- Key Features:
- Dynamic Widgets for better customization.
- Satellite SOS+ for emergency communication.
- Supports spatial video recording.
User & Expert Feedback:
Expert reviews highlight its video editing prowess as top-tier. However, users note the slower wired charging seems outdated compared to rivals.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Powered by Snapdragon 8 Gen 3, the Galaxy S24 Ultra is built for speed and efficient multitasking. Paired with One UI 7 based on Android 15, this phone offers deep customization.
Top Technical Specs:
- Chipset: Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 with 12GB/16GB RAM options.
- Storage: Options up to 1TB.
- AI Features:
- Galaxy AI tools for photo editing and smart notifications.
- Real-time transcription for calls.
User & Expert Feedback:
Users appreciate its smooth AI integration and multitasking capabilities. Gaming enthusiasts love its thermal cooling feature, although its regional chipset variability is a slight downside.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
The Pixel 9 Pro thrives with smart AI tools, thanks to the Tensor G4 processor. Though it’s not as fast as the Snapdragon or A18, its AI features make daily tasks easier.
Top Technical Specs:
- Chipset: Tensor G4 with 16GB RAM.
- AI Enhancements:
- Call Notes for transcription during calls.
- Gemini Live Assistant for advanced conversation handling.
- Storage Options: 128GB to 1TB.
User & Expert Feedback:
Loved for its AI-driven software, though gamers might find it less thrilling due to its slower performance speeds.
Performance Winner: iPhone 16 Pro Max overtakes with speed, while the Galaxy S24 Ultra balances power with multitasking features. The Pixel 9 Pro wins for its smart integrations.
3. Camera Capabilities
The camera is a key feature for most smartphone buyers, and these three don’t disappoint.
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
With a 48MP primary sensor and CineFocus AI, the iPhone offers stunning portraits and videos. Apple continues its streak of excellent low-light photography.
Top Camera Specs:
- Main Camera: 48MP wide lens with optical image stabilization.
- Zoom: 5x optical zoom and 15x digital.
- Video Recording: 4K HDR video at 120fps.
User Opinions:
- Ideal for Instagram enthusiasts and cinematographers.
- Portrait mode produces crisp and vibrant results.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Boasting a 200MP camera, Samsung dominates pixel count and flexibility. It features Nightography 2.0, which enhances low-light contexts massively.
Top Camera Specs:
- Main Camera: 200MP wide lens.
- Zoom Capability: 5x telephoto plus 50x software zoom.
- Special Features:
- Space Zoom for astrophotography.
User Opinions:
- Users love its zoom abilities for landscape and object photography.
- Some feel color enhancements could use more balance.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
The Pixel is all about computational photography. Its AI-powered enhancements result in professional-looking images every time.
Top Camera Specs:
- Main Camera: 50MP wide lens with Macro Mode.
- Editing Tools:
- Magic Eraser for removing unwanted objects.
- Best Take to perfect group shots.
User Opinions:
- Perfect for everyday users who like to tweak their photos.
- Telephoto lens performs slightly below Galaxy’s massive zoom.
Camera Winner: For extreme zoom and detail, pick the Galaxy S24 Ultra. For consistent results, go for the iPhone 16 Pro Max, while creatives may favor the Pixel 9 Pro.
4. Battery Life & Charging
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
With 17.5 hours of video playback, the iPhone lasts longer than any Apple phone to date. Though MagSafe Ultra is faster this year, wired charging still lags at 20W max.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
A robust 5,200mAh battery powers the S24 all day. Pair that with 45W fast charging and 25W wireless, and it’s a winner for busy users.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Efficient and compact, the Pixel lasts 13.5 hours. Its 30W charging speed might not wow power users, but casual ones won’t complain much.
Battery Winner: The iPhone 16 Pro Max offers unmatched battery efficiency, while Galaxy S24 Ultra wins for fast charging.
Comparison Of Best Smartphones To Buy In December 2024
| Feature | iPhone 16 Pro Max | Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra | Google Pixel 9 Pro |
|---|---|---|---|
| Display | 6.9-inch Super Retina XDR OLED | 6.8-inch Quad HD+ AMOLED | 6.3-inch OLED |
| Resolution | 2796 x 1290 pixels | 3120 x 1440 pixels | 2400 x 1080 pixels |
| Processor | A18 Pro Chip (6-core CPU, 16-core Neural Engine) | Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 | Tensor G4 |
| RAM | 8GB | 12GB / 16GB | 16GB |
| Storage Options | 256GB, 512GB, 1TB | 256GB, 512GB, 1TB | 128GB, 512GB, 1TB |
| Main Camera | 48MP wide lens with 5x optical zoom | 200MP wide lens with 5x optical zoom | 50MP wide lens with macro mode |
| Additional Camera Features | 4K HDR video, 15x digital zoom | 50x software zoom, Space Zoom | Magic Eraser, Best Take |
| Battery Life | 17.5 hours video playback | 16+ hours usage | 13.5 hours usage |
| Charging | 20W wired, MagSafe Ultra wireless | 45W wired, 25W wireless charging | 30W wired charging |
| Build Material | FrostEdge Glass & titanium frame | AeroMetal Frame with Gorilla Glass 3 | Aluminum Body |
| Water Resistance | IP68 | IP68 | IP68 |
| Operating System | iOS 18 | One UI 7 (Android 15 base) | Android 15 |
| Price | Starting at $1,199 | Starting at $1,299 | Starting at $999 |
This table provides a clear comparison of the iPhone 16 Pro Max, Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, and Google Pixel 9 Pro, making it easy to evaluate and select the phone that best fits your needs!
Smartphone Recommendation Guide with Expert Insights
Choosing the right smartphone isn’t just about specifications; expert opinions can help shed light on real-world usage. We’ve enhanced your smartphone guide with insights from leading tech reviewers to offer a clearer picture. Here’s everything you need to know about the iPhone 16 Pro Max, Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, and Google Pixel 9 Pro based on expert analysis.
1. For Photography Enthusiasts
iPhone 16 Pro Max
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- Tom’s Guide praised the iPhone 16 Pro Max’s 48MP ultrawide camera for its consistency and low-light performance, calling it an “awesome camera phone.” Its 120fps 4K video recording was singled out as a game-changer for videographers.
- The Guardian highlighted its ability to produce sharp, vibrant photos, calling its camera system “one of the most advanced on an iPhone.” However, it fell short in zoom capabilities compared to Android rivals.
Why Choose It?
Perfect for users who value seamless photography and professional-grade video recording with reliable results, especially for capturing social media-ready photos or creative projects.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- Thurrott raved about its 200MP main camera, noting significant improvements in low-light performance and zoom clarity. The 5x optical zoom lens delivers balanced images, while its AI processing ensures excellent dynamic range.
- TechRadar crowned it the “most versatile camera phone,” perfect for capturing a variety of shots, from landscape photography to astrophotography.
Why Choose It?
A dream phone for those who want unmatched versatility. If you regularly use zoom features, low-light, or wide-angle shots, the Galaxy S24 Ultra has you covered.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- While not directly reviewed in the sources used, the Google Pixel 9 Pro’s AI-powered features like Magic Eraser and Best Take remain popular for post-shot editing. Its 50MP primary sensor is reliable but lags in sheer resolution compared to the Galaxy’s 200MP sensor.
Why Choose It?
Best suited for budget-conscious creatives who enjoy polished, AI-enhanced photography.
2. For Gamers and Power Users
iPhone 16 Pro Max
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- Tom’s Guide highlighted its A18 Pro chip, providing “blazing-fast performance.” Gamers found it excels in graphics-heavy titles like Resident Evil Village with smooth frame rates and no overheating issues.
- The 6.9-inch Super Retina XDR OLED display was appreciated for vibrant colors and lag-free touch response.
Why Choose It?
If you’re in the Apple ecosystem and need power for editing, gaming, or multi-tasking apps, the iPhone 16 Pro Max shines.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- According to Thurrott, this Android flagship “outperforms most competing devices, including the Pixel 8 Pro” in terms of gaming, thanks to the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 chipset and up to 16GB RAM.
- TechRadar added that its 120Hz Quad HD+ AMOLED display guarantees ultra-smooth graphics for gaming enthusiasts.
Why Choose It?
This is a powerhouse for hardcore gamers. Its S Pen also doubles as a handy tool for productivity, making it ideal for multitaskers.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- The Tensor G4 delivers reliable performance but doesn’t compare with the beastly processors on the iPhone and Galaxy. That said, it works well for casual gaming and day-to-day multitasking.
Why Choose It?
If you lean towards less resource-intensive gaming, the Pixel 9 Pro will suffice while keeping costs lower.
3. For Budget-Conscious Users
iPhone 16 Pro Max
Why Consider It?
Although it starts at $1,199, Apple’s longevity in software support (with regular iOS updates) maximizes your investment.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Why Consider It?
Starting at $1,299, it’s pricey but includes premium hardware and features that justify its cost. Discounts or trade-ins through Samsung can make it more affordable.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Why Consider It?
With a base price of $999, this is the most affordable among the three, offering flagship-like performance and an excellent camera system.
Expert Consensus:
- For long-term savings combined with advanced features, Google Pixel 9 Pro takes the crown of budget flagship.
4. For Ecosystem Preference
iPhone 16 Pro Max
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- Apple users will love the new Apple Intelligence feature noted by The Guardian, introducing AI-based text tools for better interaction between devices.
- Seamless integration with AirPods, Macs, and Apple Watches makes this a no-brainer for Apple loyalists.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Expert Opinion Highlights:
- Thurrott praised Samsung’s DeX functionality, transforming your phone into a desktop-like interface when connected to monitors.
Why Choose It?
Customization fans and those in Samsung’s ecosystem (e.g., Galaxy Watch, Buds) will appreciate its seamless syncing.
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Why Choose It?
For users engaged in Google’s ecosystem, from Chromebooks to Google Home devices, the Pixel excels with one-touch integration.
Final Expert Recommendations
- Best for Photography: Galaxy S24 Ultra, with its groundbreaking cameras and versatility.
- Best for Power and Gaming: iPhone 16 Pro Max, thanks to its A18 chip and exceptional battery life.
- Best Value: Google Pixel 9 Pro, offering excellent AI features at a competitive price.
By factoring in expert reviews and survey data, we’re confident you’ll find a smartphone tailored to your unique preferences. Choose wisely and transform your tech experience!